<div>
(faz @ Aug. 10 2006,11:57)</div><div id="QUOTEHEAD">QUOTE</div><div id="QUOTE">i dissagree with xahrx .
when i started training in the 70s i did a fullbody 3x a week and got great gains.</div>
Just a couple of points and I'll bow out, being out voted.
1) Basic 5x5 is a full body workout, 3 times a week.
2) As a newbie for him strength will progress naturally for a while. It makes little to no sense in my opinion to use a vanilla HST program when basic training will get you a consistent weight increase and a default HST set up of consistently increasing loads anyway. It also makes no sense for him to SD, or anyone else to SD for that matter until it's necessary, and that is when gains start plateauing.
3) When he does start using a more traditional HST approach in terms of setting a predetermined load increase and SDing beforehand, the range of weight between his beginning and end load will be fairly important, and he will need to develop his strength to take advantage of that. HST isn't optimal for strength for most people. And as a newbie, his maxes are likely not that big off the bat. He can expect reasonable strength gains for a while so it makes little to no sense in my mind to have him working with submaximal weights, except for practicing form, when he can get away with using a more effective weight because his gains are likely to be pretty speedy in the beginning.
And finally in the end I think a designed strength routine would be of more benefit to someone starting out than a full body routine they design themselves or snark off the web. I just think the volume phase of a five by five serves a lot of purposes. It introduces lifters to the basic core lifts everyone should know. The manipulation of workload gives an idea of how to handle volume much better than any other program I believe. The workout is very complete in that the core lifts hit all major muscle groups so people can learn how to balance their training along those lines.
For all those reasons I think the 5x5 would be better, and better to use as a general workout approach until he decides what his goals are, which incidentally none of us bothered asking him. What if he's an olympic ice skater?
That said, HST to me is a more advanced routine that people who have a good diet and all their basics dialed in can use to great effect if their goal is gaining mass. For newbies I always start them basic, and you can't get more basic than the volume phase of a 5x5 approach. And assuming he does want to gain mass, why has no one but me mentioned the importance of diet?