<div>
(abanger @ Sep. 01 2009,4:26)</div><div id="QUOTEHEAD">QUOTE</div><div id="QUOTE">...will the HST book default to
superior methods as found in Max-Stimulation & Myo-Reps?</div><div>
(Bryan Haycock @ Sep. 01 2009,1:42)</div><div id="QUOTEHEAD">QUOTE</div><div id="QUOTE">Now, not all methods will be equally effective, but if they adhere to the basic tenants they will induce growth to some extent and/or at some rate.
After reading the book, a person should be able to assertain the pros and cons of any method.</div>
I think the key here is to be able to evaluate your progress in accordance to the basic tenets, no matter what method you use. The science gives us clues to what we need to do to keep progressing.
Both MS and MR manages fatigue, but if you dig into the science behind these methods you will find they are the opposite in what they aim for (in terms of signalling pathways and type of primary stimuli), although in practice they look very much the same.
MS and MR are both methods that adhere to the basic HST tenets mechanical and progressive load, but what about chronic stimuli and strategic deconditioning? You need to continue adressing the factors that affect recovery and conditioning to the load (RBE) to keep on progressing. We all know that this depends on our current conditioning and recovery capacity, wich may vary from bout to bout. We can affect this by adjusting volume, frequency, intensity, density, or even type of exercise, but also by covering aspects such as sleep, nutrition and other stress factors. No method can cover all of these aspects. Only you yourself can, on an individual basis. And that requires experience and willingness to keep record of your progress (or lack of), and know which parameters to adjust.
To claim one method as superior is perhaps pre-mature. They all have their use in the grand matrix of hypertrophy-specific training. You just have to figure out when to use what, and to what extent, and thus, why.
Basic, huh..?
Edit: The basic tenants have moved out in favor for the basic tenets! <<copy-paste>> Thanks, Lol!