Hey Lol - Just watched the squat vid. It may have been the angle of the view - but coming out of the hole it looks like you are getting a tiny bit stuck with your torso forward before straightening out for the rest of the eccentric portion of the movement. As you said, a slightly wider stance may really help that with a more natural body position but the struggle to keep knees in check grows as the stance widens. Regardless - seeing you do a full squat movement is refreshing; I never, ever see folks doing full squats in my gym.
Enjoy the show - for 8+ hours of travel, this must be a solid act live. Good luck in the nutrition game!!!!!!!!
Thanks, Tim. It was a great show. I'm a bit of a prog' rock head, so the bands I travel to see are unknown and go unheard by the majority of the population. Still, I love it. Sanguine Hum were worth every motorway-mile.
As a bonus, Steve Wilson, of Porcupine Tree fame, came along to enjoy the band too. Ex-XTC guitarist, Dave Gregory, was also there, playing a set with Tin Spirits. (His other current band, Big Big Train, are knocking out some fine English-flavoured prog and I hope to catch them some time soon.)
Arrived home at 5 am. and finally got to bed at 7 am. Not a great start to the day and consequently I didn't get around to training, so that's two days off. I shall be grateful.
Re squat form: oh yeah, I hear you and thanks for your thoughts, guys. It's very much a work-in-progress.
I definitely have tight hips. I am working on them like crazy! If you like, try this test: sit cross-legged on the floor, then try to drop your knees down towards the floor. Easy or hard? If you put the soles of your feet together and pull your feet in towards you as far as possible, holding your toes, while maintaining an erect torso, how far down can you drop your knees now? Mine are a good 16" up from the ground and that's after working on my hip flexibility for quite a while. I have a mate who has no difficulty dropping his knees down to the floor. He does no flexibility training at all! Genetics, eh? :-/
I have heard of the term "Scottish hip." Not sure if that's what I have? What it means for me is that it's really uncomfortable squatting with a stance that is even a little wider than shoulder-width. Because I find it so hard to drop down between my legs into a deep high-bar squat, a get my hips to come forward, I tend to end up having to lean a bit more forward coming out of the hole. As well as my hip tightness, I have ankle tightness too along with my knee-caving syndrome.
Not having fixed these issues has lead to my getting niggling right-knee discomfort that rears its ugly head every time I squat with any load around ~5RM, front or back squat. My right ankle is tighter than my left so that may be the primary cause; but it may be the fact my right leg knee tends to cave more than my left if I'm not careful.
I'm going to have to do some more form experiments. Having watched loads of different people squatting, it's very apparent that there are many variations in form that no doubt are brought about through variations in anthropometry and joint alignment/mobility. Eg:
Jon North squats with a narrow stance and seems to keep his form looking pretty good and with good depth. He has way better ankle flexibility than me so that must be part of my problem.