Well if you really want my opinoin...hehe.
Here goes.
1. I don't think protein is that big of a deal and I have seen tons of people do fine with adequate amounts.
2. I think its extremely hard for the majority of people to overtrain.
3. Around overtraining I will say that I have done it before but what indeed overtraining was for me was a matter of me not following a program that incorporated decent frequency (twice a week) and more importantly progressive load.
4. I think Reeves Physique is Awesome!
5. A lot of people who want to be big tend to extremely BULK to much and are to scared what a good cut will do to you. Just like when it comes to lifting weights you have to check your ego with proper form. The same is true with dieting. You have to check your weight at the door. I will dare say the majority of people who have what I would called PHENOMENAL bodies weigh around 170 to 200 at max!
6. To rant and have fun on point number 5! I think too many people walk around in a off season bulk state that they never get to show off there lean gains.
7. I think that SCIENCE is great but in the end Its just that science.
8. The perfect routine to me is basically do as many reps or sets as you want as long as it doesn't hender your 2 a week frequency per muscle group and more importantly it doesn't hurt your progressive loading.
Basically any routine with sufficient calories, decent protein and hitting a muscle group at least twice a week with non retarded low or high volume will work!
Wow....I typed a lot and didn't even know I could count to 8!