Not so. Those shouldn't be done with big weights compared to deads, since your erector spinae are doing most of the lift, and with the sldl's (which compare to these) are doing almost ALL the lift. It's no different than hypers, and I should probably be doing one of them myself, having been weak in this area by trying to "save" it from back pain.
I had no idea that by excluding stuff like this, I was exacerbating the pain by making that area weaker, but there ya go. Dr. Sarno's book, Healing Back Pain, dealt exactly with that stuff after the mental aspects of it all. I never would have thought I'd be doing squats and deads again...and a 435 dead at 53 wasn't shabby after 30+ years of back pain! (supposedly caused by a 'crushed disc') - I still have the same disc, but very little pain.
I'm thinking lately that we do deads for legs, mostly - but back second. Since I fail at the floor, I may need more back work, even though the movement is initiated by the legs, or is supposed to be. I'm going to talk to our local PL coach and gym owner today.
I had no idea that by excluding stuff like this, I was exacerbating the pain by making that area weaker, but there ya go. Dr. Sarno's book, Healing Back Pain, dealt exactly with that stuff after the mental aspects of it all. I never would have thought I'd be doing squats and deads again...and a 435 dead at 53 wasn't shabby after 30+ years of back pain! (supposedly caused by a 'crushed disc') - I still have the same disc, but very little pain.
I'm thinking lately that we do deads for legs, mostly - but back second. Since I fail at the floor, I may need more back work, even though the movement is initiated by the legs, or is supposed to be. I'm going to talk to our local PL coach and gym owner today.