Tot wrote:
<div></div><div id="QUOTEHEAD">QUOTE</div><div id="QUOTE">I just think it is harmful for you to tell people not to do refeeds when the majority are going to need them to successfully get in the sub-10% range without losing tons of muscle.</div>
I suggested no refeeds because, I believe, ildotter asked
me what
my strategy was, and do I use refeeds. I wasn't deliberately forcing my opinions on him. That is what sparked the discussion in the first place.
And let me be clear...I've gotten my information and strategical approach from a
professional trainer, who personally worked me through my cut. He's a CSCS, LDN, and an RD to boot (registered dietician). An RD is not anything like a mere nutritionist. The blokes at Vitamine Shoppe call themselves "nutritionists". This trainer has numerous powerlifting titles under his belt, and has trained/does train professional bodybuilders and athletes. It's because of his tutilige that I'm no slouch in the strength department, either, by the way.
His stance? Refeeds are prohibitive in the manner you suggest...or Lyle, or U2D, or whatever it's called. Period. In his opinion, these things are just the "flavor of the month." Wait and see how much you're talking about refeeds in the next few years.
Now, you can point me to all the studies in the world saying the opposite, and you're right...it's doubtful that I will read them. My trainer tells me it's a bad idea, and that's the end of the discussion. And I know his opinion is nonbiassed becase he's not trying to
sell me anything. My success is the bottom line, and he has the education, experience & knowlege to back up what he says.
Going from 15 to 10%? Fine, use refeeds, which are more a function of poor will power than absolute necessity. But refeed with carbs during the "final push" to 6-pack land, or, "stage ready"? Bad idea.
And lest you think otherwise, Tot, this is not a personal attack. All I'm saying to you is, I'm willing to bet you all the tea in China that you will never get to the level of leanness you want by using this approach. But here again, when you're done with your diet, post a pic showing the abs, and I'll tip my cap to you.
Sci wrote:
<div></div><div id="QUOTEHEAD">QUOTE</div><div id="QUOTE">Well Slapshotz, there are guys who got more lean than you using UD2 with pics to prove it at bodyrecomposition.com forum. I haven't read the book, but alot of people use it to get super-lean, I am talking fitness or bodybuilding stage lean. I have never been close to that lean, which is one reason why I didn't read it yet, a simple caloric deficit works to get to 10% or so as you said earlier.</div>
I gotta laugh....sci,
of course there are people leaner than me....just about everywhere there will always be people leaner than you, bigger than you, stronger than you, etc., but let me be clear: the only reason I didn't go down to the 3-4% range was the mental toll it was taking, and it would be hard for me to function in my everday life if I took that route. I believe I stated quite clearly that I took the diet as far as my will power was willing to go....which truly ends up being the case for most people, they just won't admit it.
So, go ahead and post all the pics you want of those who got ripped using refeeds....my point is, those people are not
you, nor are they tot...and if you both end up getting shredded using that formula? I'll eat humble pie, and gladly apologize, and be genuinely happy for your success.
Now, it's time for lunch...20 grams of net carbs, don't you know